SplitAtCorners seems to be on strike

Hi @DanielPiker , the “SplitAtCorners” is one of those super-useful utilities that I would love to see become more robust.

Here, it just won’t do anything :
SpliAtCorners on strike.gh (13.2 KB)

Any idea why ?

Hi
Shouldn’t it be a polyline?

It is not a Polyline, two segments are not linear

2 Likes

OK, I get it : I see that some of the segments of my polyline are not lines, thus it’s in fact a poly-curve.
So this is the opportunity to let out a mini-rant about the many curve types GH distinguishes, yet the little means of filtering and sorting we have apart from the text description in the panel :

To me, there should be a more rigorous classification :
PLANARITY : Planar / Non-Planar
COMPOSITION : Single / Poly
TYPOLOGY : Lines / Curves / Mixed
PERIODICITY : Periodic / Non-periodic
TERMINATION : Closed / Open

The text description of a curve should comprise all of it’s above characteristic, which would be more useful in the end.

@DavidRutten ? Wouldn’t that be a nice feature in GH2 ?
As a math stickler, you should be seduced by this idea :wink:
Something similar could be said about surfaces, BTW.

1 Like

You were faster than me :slight_smile:
Yet, don’t you think that @DanielPiker could make this component even more useful by allowing polycurves ? After all, the angle at corners is also defined with “curved” curves.

1 Like

I always use Mesh corners

1 Like

An example of ambiguity with curve types is the “Polyline Through points” command in Rhino.
It allows to set the degree of the resulting curve (which in the case of deg=3 becomes a single curve, and not a “Poly-Curve” !), thus contradicting the very name of the command…

I originally wrote this just for accessing sides of meshes to assign different strengths to individual boundary cables, and there the input would always be a polyline.
I agree though that it could be useful to have something more general, so here’s a new scripted component that also works with polycurves.
Apart from accepting polycurves it is the same as the polyline one - it takes an angle threshold above which to split, and outputs a list of corners and segments.
curve_splitter.gh (6.1 KB)
(I can add this as a standard component to the next release)

2 Likes

Super !
Thank-you Daniel.
Apparently, there’s something it doesn’t like about that curve though :
curve_splitter bug.gh (8.3 KB)

That’s bizarre. Here’s what I get when opening your file and setting the angle threshold to 6 degrees. All the kinks are properly shown. Which version of Rhino are you testing in?

Rhino 6 SR23 2020-1-31

Is it perhaps finding all 17 kink points and just not displaying them?

Nope, it finds only 8
My file is in millimeters BTW.

Works for me too :wink:

DUh… my Angle Tolerance was set to 1°
I’ve set it to 0.1°, and now it works.

1 Like