Clipping section drawings - Section Style - Boundary / Print Color Bug

Hi, could Rhino developers reconsider allowing user to change clipping section drawings lines’ Print Color? Normally I would like to set their Print Color “By Layer”. Currently there is no such option. The lines’ Print Color is always set to “By Display”.

I hope I described the problem well.
Unfortunately it makes Clipping Section Drawing completely unusable! :-/

Thanks! :slight_smile:

PS: alternatively, you could implement it in the following way (which seems to be easier)
In the Section Styles, “Boundary” setting should have an effect not only on the cipped view (eg. in perspective view) but also on the Clipping Section Drawings.
In the very same way that “Hatch” setting works!
Rhino 8.1

Mac version seems to have the same bug! Please help us! :open_mouth:

Can you tell me why this makes it completely unusable? What problem are you tryin to solve?

Can you please attach a 3dm file that shows what doesn’t work?

Clipping Section Drawing, as far as I understand it, is meant for representation of a 3d object.
If such 2d representation is limited in terms of colors (no way to set its print color), then I claim it is a major flaw (a bug, I guess).

I appreciate your willingness to help. However, would 3dm file really help?
Isn’t it clear yet where the problem is? If so, let me know :–)

@michalc

Sending models helps a lot. Rhino has hundreds of commands, thousands of options, and many different ways to configure sections. If you can:

  1. Send me a file
  2. Send a screenshot or PDF file of what you see now
  3. Describe what you wish was different

Then I can look at all the things you send and see if we can enhance or fix this. Otherwise, I’d just be guessing, sending you a new build, and hoping we guessed correctly.

Hello @brian ,
I believe this is related to what Michal is talking about. I have print preview ON on the layout view, and instead of section styles using the pattern color, it is using whatever color is set for the print color for the layer. I want the section to be white as seen on my screenshot, I have white set as the pattern color but instead (with the print preview on) the section turns black since that’s what I set the print color to be for the layer. I am using clipping section views to produce the drawing.

It would be nice to have the drawing printed while following the set color for the pattern and boundary.

my current Solution is to use ExtractClippingSections with ‘hatch’ set on and curves set off, this gives me a copy of the section style hatching that doesn’t get affected by the layer print color, unfortunately, it is not dynamic so I have to reuse the command every time I change the clipping plane/section location.

Thanks, logged as RH-78947 Print Color for Sections Not Available

Second this. Wish we get to adject boundary print color one day soon.

Hi there,
I can only confirm this.
When working with renovations, where color coding is very important, a 3D workflow seems not possible. Really a mayor drawback.
Is there any chance this will be fixed soon?

Kind regards,
Gabriel

Since 8.2 the print color is tied to the objects display color. Does that not help?

Hey @brian, I think this is the problem they are referring to. As you can see in the screenshots, the section style for the bricks is set to a solid light gray, and it does show it as solid light gray when the clipping plane is cutting through the object. But when i create a clipping drawing for it, the brick hatch turns to solid black, instead to a solid light gray.

Furthermore as you can see in the 3rd image, same problem goes for boundary lines too, neither the hatch colour or boundary colour is carried on to the section drawing. E.g. the section style setting are for the middle object, the hatch colour is gray and boundary is set to Cyan. But the drawing still comes out as full black.

Seems like this is still a problem in the latest 8.22 version. I do have print display on and it still doesn’t fix it.

I’ve put that issue on the list as RH-89774 ClippingDrawings: Object Print Color

I don’t think so - but, yes, without 3dm files, all we can do is try to interpret some text…
I’ve put what I believe you are reporting on the list as RH-89775 ClippingDrawings: Output Hatch Properties
-wim

Hey @wim thanks for the update, I was checking up on the report post, and Rajaa Issa commented about using DisplayColour- ByInputObject. The problem with this method is all the other lines in the drawing inherit the layer colour. Thus killing the organizational aspect of Rhino, if i have to set all the layers to black in order to create a clipping drawing. I have added a test .3dm file with clipping drawing output from both DisplayColour setting.
I can’t share this project file for obvious reasons, but here is a screenshot as to what happens and the messed up quality of drawing you get with ByInputObject. By using this method, firstly the boundary line of the cut object gets coloured of the layer colour, secondly if you check the “AddBackground” the drawing shows the background objects as a coloured with the layer colour.
I do not have access to interact with RH-89775, so I have to share this with you here.

Clipping Drawing Hatch.3dm (152.3 KB)

Like this is drawing I get when I do DisplayColour- ByInputObject. Which is really not good, if there is a way to only get the hatch coloured.

This issue (still persisting in Version 8 (8.29.26063.11002,) has cost me now close to 12 working hours as I try figuring out the system (which seems to be just completely buggy) or trying to find a workaround with clipping planes instead of section drawings. But the clipping planes come with their own faults: Section Style not working for Blocks - #16 by ice

Expected behaviour (necessary for an architectural workflow):

  • When defining the section style in the layers panel and choosing solid fill as hatch, the colour of the hatch only turns out black. Contrary to the normal behaviour when you just fill a rectangle with a hatch. The hatch takes on the colour of the layer. I couldn’t find a workaround to get a solid fill hatch with another colour than black. The pattern colour should follow the layer colour of the layer on which the object lays that is being clipped . Is there a way?

  • The clipping drawing creates differing colours for the same cut object. When printing the plan it’s being printed the correct way, so it seems to be an issue only in the layout viewport (printdisplay on and off).

So, unfortunately, with the current behaviour of the clipping drawings, it makes it completely unusable which seems really odd to me since this feature was introduced as a major/minor feature of Rhino 8 but apparently has not been tested at all for a professional workflow. And it seems, according to some of the bug tracking sites, they will only be addressed in Rhino 9 :thinking:

Hi Viktor -

In a new file from a factory-default template, if you only change a layer’s section style to place a solid hatch, the hatch color will be the layer color.

From your description, it’s impossible for me to know what you are doing differently.

Please post that 3dm file.
-wim

RH-78947 is fixed in Rhino WIP

has this issue " RH-89775" been resolved? As of rhino 8 SR35, background colour for pattern hatch in section style still remove all clipping boundaries of the model. Will it be resolved anytime soon?

Hi C1 -

RH-89775 was resolved in Rhino 9.
-wim