Wrong shading in Concept mode

Yeah, I wonder…

But I don’t get why they show all the tangent edges, though.

And I guess it’s a bit buggy still (there’s no meshes in this shot):

EDIT: Actually, no it’s a new Beta bug… here’s my Technicolor viewport mode on that same object (which has worse, grainy shading in V9 than V8 sadly):

And here it is shaded…

@eobet do you see this on all objects? If it is object specific, can you send that object?

All objects all files for me. Again, done a lot of factory resetting and OptionsMigrate, so settings should be clean/transferred from V8.

I will try to reproduce this by loading your display setting in Rhino 8 and then an option migrate.

@eobet I can’t reproduce this here.

As for the grainy shadows, this can be fixed by increasing the skylight slider from 0 to 3-4

pls run _SystemInfo and post back the results. And from Rhino BETA, if you can run OptionsExport and send the .rhs to me I can at least verify if it something in the options itself or something else.

systeminfo.txt (2.2 KB)

rhs in upload.

Any way to turn off ambient occlusion? In V8, the technical shadow mode had more of a toon shader look which suited it better, imo.

hi @eobet
I think I found the cause of what you are seeing, can you confirm you were using (rotated) blocks?

RH-97590 Messed up monochrome shading with transformed blocks

RH-97590 is fixed in Rhino BETA

Yes, seems to be fixed in latest beta thanks.

But again, how do I turn the ambient occlusion completely off?

This is supposed to be a technical view mode which looks very clean in V8:

Yet this ugly in V9:

I don’t want the ambient occlusion smoother, I need it to be completely gone. A flat surface should have a single color just like in technical view modes in V8.

You need to use “scene lighting” and remove/switchoff the skylight.

I could not get this to work, and even with “no lighting” I still see the ambient occlusion so I strongly suspect that it is a separate effect decoupled from any lighting but I can’t find the button to switch it off (without also turning of the shadows of the technical display mode).

This is what I get when I use scene lighting without sun and without skylight. Of course there is a slight shading effect depending on the orientation of the surfaces, but this is exactly what takes place in your “clean” example from Rhino8.

Thanks!

But imo that’s problematic, because when I then switch to rendered view, I have to open the lights panel and toggle those lights on… I still consider this a regression.

In V8, I can toggle between rendered and technical views with one click.

If either of the “lighting method” options “default” or “no lighting” looked like it does when you manually switch off all lights in the light panel, then I would have no complaints but they don’t. They both force ambient occlusion on which I still hope McNeel developers will consider as a bug.

Okay, now I get it.

The lighting in Pen mode is very different in version 9 compared to v8, even with default lighting selected and skylight turned off.

Probably something completely changed in the display pipeline?

Right, so @Gijs could we please get this classified as a regression so it can get a fix before V9 release?