WISH - SWEEP and LOFT to make SOLID when Flat faces

@Gijs,
I don’t know how complex it could be but I’m experiecing more and more young student asking why Sweep and Loft won’t generate solid when the start ant end face is closed.

My wish is to have a check button (or a general option like creasesplitting) that does, under the hood, the cap holes after the surface command.

If I make architectural pieces, like a handrail, it would be better to generate a closed solid instead of an open surface.

Thanks
Riccardo

A simple macro
…loft …or … sweepX…

Selnone
Sellast
Cap

Will do it

RH-89961 Sweep: add a Solid option

RH-89962 Loft: add a Solid option

RH-89964 Revolve: Add Solid option

RH-89966 Sweep2: Add a Solid option

unless you want History

talking about history…
then adding a copy option and history support to cap would be the nice

and if we want to get better history - sketches + constraints is the biggest missing puzzle piece and an history-browser that shows dependencies…

Thanks Tom,
I’m aware of this but I always find hard to explain student that are new to Rhino why they have to create a custom code for an “expected” function like this.
It’s also hard to teach them this convoluted way of work especially if they’re architects and eventually coming from Sketchup

I’m also teaching Onshape and, apart for the tree features, it works the same way: flat sections extrude solid, non flat sections extrude only as surfaces.

Exactly becasue it look a simple hack I wish it could be implemented, at least as global option (like Sweep solid = yes/no)