Why is this sweep not working?


#1

Hello there,

I am trying to sweep the red profile on the black rail/rails.

Neither Sweep1 or Sweep2 work.

What am I doing wrong here? I can visualise the shape but I can’t create it.

Thanks for your time,

Voula


(Diego Krause) #2

seems like you have to either split some curves and make several sweeps or change the input curves completely.


(Pascal Golay) #3

Hi Voula - that is not a setup that can work with a sweep of any kind, that I can see - Sweep2 uses the two rails as edges of the surface and the ‘shape’ curves as, well, shapes, between the rails. The result is a ‘rectangular’ shape bounded by the rails on two opposite sides. Do you have an image of the shape you’s like to result from these curves?

-Pascal


#4

If I try to do SWEEP 2, just with the black curves to the left, as indicated rail 1 and rail 2, I get a surface that dips in one corner. How can I avoid this? Why is this happening? Overall the resulting surface is desirable, but in a sense ruined by that diving in one corner.

If I try to do SWEEP 1, joining the two previous rails, the surface is unusable.

If I forget the sweeps and generate the surface from CURVE NETWORK, incorporating all curves in the design, the resulting surface is very close to what I need to produce.

But I am trying to understand why the SWEEP goes wrong. Should the red profile be oriented differently? but if I change its orientation I would have to have a different profile curve.
Thanks again

If I try to


#5

Diego,

see comment I left below.
Thanks for your time.


(Diego Krause) #6

something like this maybe?

is tricky to understand what do you want without the file or even an example.


#7


Trying to recreate this object. It is the spoke of a wheel of an ancient chariot.
Contains 3 parts: the upper 2 spokes that are larger and look a bit like a gold clubs, the lower 2 spokes that is smaller, and the “button” in the middle. Currently trying to figure out the shape of the lower, smaller spokes.

Thank you very much for your suggestion. I have tried to solve this for the last 10 days but keep coming to a dead end.


(Eliel) #8

There are a variety of strategies to recreate this model in particular, in this case use the loft command and then cut it with the curves shown in the image
you can try the following method.


(Pascal Golay) #9

??

-Pascal


(Diego Krause) #10

I’m making a video. later I will upload it:



#11

Amazing! Thank you very much everyone. I am so grateful for the advice -
Honestly, the Rhino Forum is a TREASURE.

Ps: Diego, I will be waiting for the video as well.


(Diego Krause) #12

here is the video:


#13

Fantastic Diego!
Much obliged


#14


Hello Diego,
more spokes giving me trouble. These are a variation of the previous theme. I can’t get the upper and lower spokes to join as they appear in the clay model. Any suggestions would be much appreciated!


(Diego Krause) #15

how many videos you will need? I can make a quote for that haha. this new spoke can be made from different aproach, I will check it later.


#16

Haha Name your price!

Looking forward to your next posting.