Why does the split fail

“Hi everyone, I have a question about a split operation. In the orthographic views, a line and an object are clearly intersecting, but I’m unable to split the object with the line. When I use the `Intersect` command, I found that their intersection is only a single point. What’s strange is that this operation works perfectly in Rhino 7, but it fails in Rhino 8. If I then move the line by just 0.001 units, it splits successfully in Rhino 8 as well. Could anyone explain why this is happening? Thank you all very much.”

cant split.3dm (110.2 KB)

OK,

Firstly, your 180mm long part was 31,000mm from the origin - not likely far enough to cause issues, but best practice to to be as close to the world origin as you can.

Next, did you need 0.0001 document tolerance? How is the part going to be made? Tho in this case changing to 0.01 or 0.1mm document tolerance didnt help.

What did work was moving the line 0.01mm to the right - to move it off the exact intersection of the fillet/angle.

Also what worked was exploding the model, splitting the parts and joining together the parts for each of the two pieces.

Cheers

DK

did split.3dm (135.6 KB)

Thanks again for the help. I tried changing the tolerance to 0.001 and moving the object to the origin, but the split still fails. Exploding it and splitting the surfaces individually does work, though. I’m still unclear on the root cause for the polysurface split failure. You mentioned it was ‘off the exact intersection of the fillet/angle’. Could you elaborate on what that means and if that’s the reason for the failure? Thank you

Hello again,

In this picture your splitting line is selected, and I’ve added a second line 0.01mm to the right of you line, unselected in the picture - I’ve zoomed WAY in to show the issue.

Your line is on the EXACT intersection of a couple of trimmed surfaces - this is typical of where Rhino trims and Booleans fail, the maths just cannot resolved. The line that is moved 0.01 off this point splits the polysurface perfectly and is likely accurate enough for what ever the final product is.

This is Rhino, and this stuff happens, as you get more experience to tend to not create this sort of geometry in the first place and/or learn the quick work arounds.

Cheers

DK

:+1: :+1: :+1: Thank you for sharing your experience. You’re right, perhaps it’s best to avoid creating this kind of geometry

Extrude the line to cross through the model you want to trim, then use the surface to trim the model. Lines and curves in Rhino often fail to trim polysurfaces.

I’ve tried that. The surface extruded from the line fails to cut it as well

"It works on the left side, but fails on the right. I’m completely confused. Why

thanks @chenjiajin for reporting.

RH-89126 Split fails

fwiw: I managed to split by intersecting a plane with the polysurface and using the resulting curve

Thank you 。:+1: 。A friend told me that if I trim the line like this, or if I move the line directly onto this endpoint, the split works. Could you test it as well? It’s amazing! WHY

Note that the file tolerance also has a setting for angle tolerance (deviation), so if the target object to be split or trimmed is too far from the cutting object or the scene origin, that introduces a greater deviation than usual.

Explode the object, split the individual surfaces then rejoin.