How To Deal With These Naked Edges

Join strategy.3dm (911.9 KB)

Now that I’ve learned how to take best advantage of join, I have 3 small naked edges left over. I’ve tried trimming behind those edges, but that doesn’t work, likely because they don’t actually come together. For these particular edges, I’m not sure what tools to employ to get rid of them. As you can see, most of the similar edges in the model joined just fine. thanks, rex

Hi Rex - in wireframe you can see the surfaces under those corner fillets are not actually trimmed back. Here it is fixed up, but it is a little bit of a nuisance to do, I’ll make you a little clip shortly so you can see some of the things to look for.

Join strategy_PG.3dm (591.9 KB)

Here’s a clip -

note I switch to Wireframe to see the structure of the thing more clearly, and I switch to parallel view when I need to zoom in really close.

The command near the end, testRemoveAllNakedMicroloops will not autocomplete on your system - type the whole thing.

-Pascal

Hello,

It looks like you could use fillet on this model on the top edge instead of trying to (sweep)? I may have used a different strategy in using mostly Booleans for this but it could be an alternate method if the corner fillets are acceptable.

Pascal, I made it through your procedure. Thanks much. I’m not sure what that final untrim border accomplished though or why it was necessary. thanks

Also, I can’t find testRemoveAllNakedMicroloops on the Mac version. Is it there? If not, how do I get rid of that open point? I use both Mac and Windows. thanks, rex

Also, when it came time to trim the two side surfaces at the edges of the little compound triangle, why was it necessary to trim with a curve rather than being able to use the triangle surface?

The reason I use the curve when trimming with fillets is that fillets by definition just barely touch the adjacent surface - when tolerances and surface to surface intersections come into play, it is not uncommon for the curve of intersection to be incomplete and/or take a long time to calculate. Since I know the edge curve is in fact the thing I want ti trim with it is quicker and more reliable to specify the edge curve using the CRV filter.

-Pascal

By monkeying with the surface control points (delete points and SetPt) the existing trimmed edge will move around. I wanted to have a new clean accurate trim.

-Pascal

Pascal, I often have this kind of problem, and it is nice to have this video to use when I try to fix them.
However I can’t say I understand totally what each step did. I won’t ask you to explain step by step here, but it would be useful to have a video with narration sometime to explain each of the steps. I think I would learn a bunch generally about the subtleties of surface editing.
For instance I have no idea what testRemoveAllNakedMicroloops does or what created the conditions that made it necessary.
Nick

Yeah… this is a bit of test command magic. It does pretty much what the command name suggests - it finds those pesky, hard to fix ‘point’ naked edges and where possible rearranges the trim, microscopically, to eliminate the looped curve.

-Pascal

It’s there, but as mentioned, being a test command it does not autocomplete- you must type the whole thing. Correctly…
(copy/paste works)
-Pascal

I now have a closed polysurface and am a lot smarter. Thank you!

Rex