Boolean fail


#1

Hi,

in the attached, boolean fails (pipe-like object - plane).
Also _wirecut fails.

As far as I see the objects are ok…

(I know how to get a solution, just wanted to report this bug.)

-C-H-A-R-L-E-S-
CP_NoBool.3dm (48.2 KB)


Rhino 5 SR9 RC1 Available
(Brian James) #2

Thanks Charles, I filed the issue.

edit: the developer commented that since the intersection is not a closed curve BooleanDifference wouldn’t work. Were you looking for it to trim?


(Brian Gillespie) #3

@BrianJ I can’t find this on YouTrack - can you please post a link here? (I searched for http://discourse.mcneel.com/t/boolean-fail but couldn’t find it).


(Brian James) #4

Here’s the YT link… http://mcneel.myjetbrains.com/youtrack/issue/RH-24922


(Brian Gillespie) #5

Thanks. In the future when you add bugs based on a discourse conversation, please add a link on Discourse to the YT item, and add link in the YT item back to the Discourse thread. This makes it easier to understand where bugs come from.


#6

Hi there, I haver a problem too. I would like to boolean diffrence (so cut the pipe) from that twisted ring but I cant. Do u have any solutions?


(Brian James) #7

I bet the issue is with the twisted ring self-intersecting. Please also post a new topic for any new questions if you can.