Violin scroll design

Hi there,

it’s been a while since I had this in mind.

I am trying to reverse the design of a violin scroll. It will be used for CNC roughing, so I prefer to get decent NURBS surfaces rather than simply oversizing an stl mesh.

The scroll is oriented with the X along its major axis and the Y along its width. The tricky thing is to create a reasonable shape in Y. that’s the mesh and the surfaces I created:

Basically I started with the side view and made the profile curve. In order to get to that point I used grasshopper to manually move the Y coordinates of the control points with sliders, until I get something good. One baked the curves I made a sweep2 between them.

I have troubles getting a decent solid from that: if I extrude the curves I used for sweep2 I can’t put a decent fillet or radius on that:

Do you have any suggestions on alternative approaches or in making a better use of the sweep and extrude curves?

Why do you need a solid? Can’t you just use NURBS surfaces and Rhino’s very well working FilletSrf tool?

It looks like it is NURBS surfaces - I think the mesh mentioned is the scan that you can see at the bottom in the first image.

If you are having trouble putting fillets on surfaces, try doing the Pipe trick or using filletsrf and working on it in small sections.

Filletsrf gives problems too, even if I duplicate and extrude the edge.

Without a V8 3D file, one can do nothing but make wild guesses.

Forum_export.3dm (231.1 KB)

here you have theV8 example. Curves simplified. As always this helps a lot.

surfaces are now being filleted correctly:

filletsrf in v9 does a lovely job here- g2 blend 1.6 units