No deformation / no internal forces in Karamba3D despite applied loads

Hi everyone,

I am currently developing a parametric design/modeling workflow for a timber-concrete composite structure with notched connections as part of my master’s thesis.

At the moment I am trying to calculate the structural system in Grasshopper using Karamba. The idea is to implement a model approach similar to the method proposed by Rautenstrauch for discontinuously connected timber-concrete composite structures.

However, I currently cannot get the model to actually calculate.

What happens:

  • Loads are applied

  • No error message is shown

  • But there is no visible deformation

  • No internal forces are returned

  • The model seems to remain “inactive” although the calculation component runs

    Stabwerkmodell.gh (66.2 KB)

Since I have been debugging this for quite some time already, I would really appreciate if someone could take a quick look at the Grasshopper file and maybe point me in the right direction.

Thanks a lot in advance!

Hi,
Not at laptop right now. By looking at the dotted wire, it seems, that you have multiple models. I guess you have to take care of your datastream, when generating it. Sometimes it’s just flatten the inputs.
Itay have another reason, just guessing.

As mentioned in a previous thread, you need to flatten your inputs in the AssembleModel because you have dashed wires, which means multiple models.

Also, I noticed that there are duplicate/overlapping curves in your model so this might also cause issues in the calculation later on.

Thanks for your help! I have been able to fix the problem, it was about a wrong connection between the analyze model and the beam view components so quite easy and actually just dump i didnt see it myself… However i am struggeling with something new no. I want to place a joint between the lower and the upper vertical trusses. I dont know if i dont get how the beam joints compinent works but for some reason the joints wont appear in my model. Can someone help me with that? I already tried to look at the example files on the karamba website but i cant see the components that were used because i have an older karamba version (v 2.2.0.180)

Stabwerkmodell_4.gh (109.5 KB)

Hi, in version 2.2, you cannot input the list of elements, but you need to put in an ID: 3.4.1: Beam-Joints :large_blue_diamond: | Karamba3D v2

For example like this: