Clipping plane & selection filter

I was running into a weird situation where I couldn’t select the clipping plane. First I couldn’t figure out what kind of object the clipping plane was so I was just trying to turn on everyting one by one and trying to select the clipping plane. It seems like Rhino now disables the selection filter every 4th time you try to select something you cannot select. My questions:

  1. Is the automatic disabling of the selection filter expected behaviour?
  2. Is there a reason why is there nothing in the selection filter to only select clipping planes? I’d expect anything that can be an object in the rhino environment would be able to be filtered.

Note in passing there is the native command SelClippingPlane

Designed behavior - yes. Expected behavior - well, people will have different opinions I guess. I personally think this is a dumb thing, I hate when software makes decisions based on what it thinks I want to do. It’s akin to Windows when you press some combination of Ctrl+Shift too many times, it asks you if you need impaired keyboard assistance. At least it asks first

I guess Clipping planes are covered in the “Others” category in the selection filter. Below is a scriptlet that will allow you to pick/select only clipping planes if it helps.

PickClippingPlanes.py (93 Bytes)

1 Like

thanks for your reply @Helvetosaur

I don’t see the “Others” category in the selection filter? Have a look at what I see on the video

Edit: It seems like “Others” was there in Rhino 7 but not in Rhino 8 anymore. I was wondering why this felt so weird that I run into this problem for the first time.

This is what I have…

And I just checked, right clicking on “Others” to set it as the unique selection type does allow me to select clipping planes.

That’s weird. I don’t have that? :confused: Is that rhino 8?

Yep… Above was from my custom workspace, but here’s what it looks like in Default:

Hmmm… weird. maybe a repair installation is in order?

(I’m running 8.5.24058.13001, 2024-02-27)

I’m running 8.4.24044.15001, 2024-02-13.
I cannot spend too much time on figuring this out now, but I’ll try some stuff and see if it gets resolved

It’s weird.

If I undock the selection filter I see “Others”
image

When I dock it back below the commandline “Others” disappears - Also not visible when I enlarge the window

Bug?

Possibly. This box is a bit weird - for example I have mine docked next to the command line and it shows me the little >> to indicate there is something not shown, but all the boxes are indeed visible…

@wim This sounds like it could use a look by the appropriate developer.

Thanks I see “Others” missing from the horizontal layout as well. RH-80712

Right-clicking to choose just one selection filter only also doesn’t seem to work when the selection filter is in the same location.

Can you tell me more? I can’t seem to repeat that issue here.

I cannot repeat it anymore either.

No worries, I’ll try to repeat more, if you get in that state again let me know.

RH-80712 is fixed in Rhino 8 Service Release 5