Can't close brep!

Grasshopper
1

Hi! This ShapeInBrep is still in red, and the alarm recalls that there is an open Brep, however, when I test the brep, they are all closed. Any idea what might be going on?
Thank you!

Screenshot%20(131)
Screenshot%20(131)1333×750 105 KB

shape in brep.gh (35.5 KB)

2

if your breps are already closed then there is no need to use boolean union

image
image1125×888 76.3 KB

1 Like
3

I take it back - I see why you’re using the union
and even if you weren’t I suppose the component should still work


But it’s faulty:

image
image1415×706 81.2 KB

no naked edges found when baked, capping doesn’t work, and boolean union leaves it ‘open’ in grasshopper
is this a bug to track @dale ?

4

@ffeldsberg, @René_Corella, the second item in the list reports as a closed non-manifold polysurface.

– Dale

5

Hi @dale ! Thank you very much for your time, but what does it mean?

6

https://docs.mcneel.com/rhino/6/help/en-us/index.htm#information/troubleshoot_boolean_operations.htm?Highlight=manifold

1 Like
7

Hi @dale, what would you say is the best way to solve the brep that can’t be closed in GH and not in rhino?

8

screenshot_01
screenshot_01.jpg932×584 73.4 KB

This looks like SUnion is doing something that changes a closed Brep to an open one.