Q: Boole mesh and NURBS?

Serengeti (Rhino WIP)
1

Hi…,

I am a mesh dummy. Shouldn’t boole (e.g. _MeshBooleanIntersection) a mesh and NURBS result in a mesh? Attached an example: Boole_Mesh_and_NURBS_does_nothing.3dm (934.2 KB)

Thanks

Michael

2

Works fine here with MeshBooleanUnion, selecting the mesh first and then the sphere.

image
image1634×1526 373 KB

Boole_Mesh_and_NURBS_does_nothing.3dm (1.1 MB)

3

Hi Martin,

thank you for your result. What Rhino are you using?

Here in the current WIP (8.0.23150.10305, 2023-05-30) nothing happens.

Thanks

Michael

4

I just realized the boolean union above was done in Rhino 7.
I’m using Rhino feeder to open files and it opened your file in Rhino 7…

I’m on the same Rhino 8 WIP like you and I see the same problem.

It seems Rhino 7 automatically converts a brep to a mesh but Rhino 8 WIP doesn’t do that.

1 Like
5

When you first _Mesh the sphere, and then _MeshBooleanUnion, the result is open:

image
image795×576 68.6 KB

Not so good (= bug).
While I like that the mesh of the cube is far better than in V7.

1 Like
6

Haha, did not see the underside of this cube is actually open. Thanks Charles.

The cleaner look of the cube in V8 is because it’s showing ngons. This can be achieved in V7 too.

7

Still the open result in (8.4.24023.15001, 2024-01-23).
Seems the issue was not logged.
@Gijs Do you know?

8

Here conversion is done to mesh, but indeed leaves an open mesh
RH-80061 MeshBooleanUnion: open result