[Unpublished opinion piece]

Pfff, that is nothing. You do realize there is a whole system in the academic world where other students take exams for other people, do their homework, etc?

In every field. You name it. Mathematics, physics, psychology, sociology, history. In every uni, specially the top ones.

Gym?

There seems to be a reason why going to the moon is no longer in fashion.

// Rolf

I did not.
I’ve never be part of anything above high school.
Sometime uni students contact me to actually get pseudo-lessons or “aimed and explained solutions”, but most of the times are situations like that one i attached.

Anyway, i realized i might have put this far off topic from initial David post. :speak_no_evil:

No I think this fits the topic somehow! Its about cheating… And yes, claiming your design is better due to the use of ML, then this is not truly honest. Why do people learn about Grasshopper in mandatory courses? Is it about teaching something truly useful, or is about an institute being “innovative” in comparision to other institutes? Its definitly not black and white, but I can tell that there is a lot of exaggeration and “hyping” going on. If you ask why do people cheat and why others are totally ok with this, then I believe its also about the motivation. So yes @Rolf is totally right, only a few people want to do things better, they rather want status . Nothing wrong with this, but this might explain the bullshit bingo :slight_smile:

this is question i was asking myself yesterday and now there is this article :slight_smile:
should the grand vision for future be computer aided design or human aided computer design?

good article, more like artsy prose

this material as proof should mean immidiate expulsion for the student

i would report those students directly with no further remorse

This is interesting, i have seen this kind of “work” offers even in professional environments, mostly because there are sites on the internet where engineers sell their work really really cheap, like 150 $us for complete structural analysis and construction plans for a 500 sq.m house…

this problem is a lot more common in technical fields, at least creative works aren’t too affected for this trend…yet

Where can I find these sites? I always thought that 150$ is the hourly rate, which seams reasonable…
But of course if this engineer is sitting in Indonesia than I guess this might be even realistic.

Hey David,
Thank you for sharing your thoughts, this was a nice read.
Bests, e

you can take a look at e.g. Fiverr…

A little OT:
I have made an Fiverr experiment 1,5 years ago to see if I could “outsource” some part of my not so complicated work …
So I put together a complete set of documents from an old project that we already did, and also attached a very comprehensive documentation how I would like this assignment (3D modelling a single family home, medium complexity) to be fulfilled.
I hired and paid 4 different guys and waited for the results. The references they showed on Fiverr looked very solid, so I thought this should not been a big challenge.

The results where of course very mixed, but at the end of the day very sobering.
I had to do a lot of babysitting and coaching to get them going in the right direction, at the end there was only one result that I would call aceptable the others: not so much…

good to know i dont need to test it myself, i trust you cause i tried fiverr for logo creation, terrible… :slight_smile: thanks

I remember reading about a guy who worked in IT but worked from home and he sub contracted his job out to someone in China. He only got caught because someone noticed his connection was from a Chinese IP address as he’d given the sub contractor his login details.
On one hand, this is terrible. On the other hand, this is genius!

just put freelancer something on google, you will be surprised, mostly engineers from asia region are really cheap and the quality of the work is not always proportional to the fee, with luck you can get a good freelancer with really cheap fees, i know of an engineer that outsources everything since 2 years and of course his costs are like half of the standard in my country.

check this video is really interesting…