V7 [image] V8 [image] V9 [image] MAF.3dm (620.1 KB) ** sys info.txt (3.5 KB) **

hi @Piotr thanks for reporting, I logged: RH-83072 MergeAllCoplanarFaces is broken in Rhino 9 WIP ps: the object is an invalid Brep, but that is not why it is failing.

I thought it may be invalid by SelBad finds nothing.

SelBadObjects works here in 7 8 and 9 to flag that object.

What do you see if you run What on that object? I see: [image]

It is valid here: :sweat_smile: [image]

interesting… are you sure you’re looking at the same file you posted?

I’ve sent an V7export after copy-pasting it from V9. Strangely, it is valid in V9 on the whole scene and becomes invalid when opened solo.

Could this be related to the mess that results in V8 and V9 when Rebuild is used on a single surface in a polysurface? Rebuild and sub-objects

I don’t remember how it was created but, for sure, Rebuild wasn’t involved.

Strange results of Merge All Faces

Serengeti (Rhino WIP)

brian (Brian Gillespie) July 23, 2024, 10:30pm 13

RH-83072 is fixed in the latest WIP

Topic		Replies	Views
Error MergeAllCoplanarFaces into invalid Brep Rhino windows	1	480	July 26, 2021
Brep.MergeCoplanarFaces() method almost always returns invalid Breps Rhino Developer windows , rhino8	5	182	August 27, 2024
MergeAllCoplanarFaces Issue Rhino for Mac mac	1	328	January 18, 2021
MergeAllCoplanarFaces and MergeAllEdges resulting in invalid breps Rhino Developer windows	2	154	September 18, 2024
Bug report: R7 merge all coplanar faces results in bad surfaces Rhino for Windows windows	6	512	February 2, 2021

Strange results of Merge All Faces

Related topics