We need to talk about Offset

rhino
(Laurent Delrieu) #1

Dear Rhino/Grasshopper developers thanks for Rhino 6, many useful improvements, render, Rhinocommon functions … but there is an old subject Polyline Offset see this thread :

Are there some news about Polyline offset ?
I know Clipper is a good solution for Grasshopper and Rhino.
Update : @pascal it is not a Grasshopper question more a Rhino core function. There is a reliability problem with offset Polyline. It doesn’t work on some the cells which are simple polygon (see the picture).
The same as in Grasshopper, I used Rhino 6 and offset multiple



And Clipper solution

Laurent


offset fail.gh (6.9 KB)

6 Likes

Curve offset
Offset problem: cannot do it with sand-form-like
Discrepancy in offset commands between Rhino native and Grasshopper
2D metaball like connection between distort forms
Is it a waste of time to report Rhino bugs?
RhinoNest in grasshopper?
Voronoi and then offset error
(Pfotiad0) #2

Laurent,

Provide your e_mail (I have a gift for you)

0 Likes

#3

Thanks for bringing this up again here. It’s been bugging me quite regularly as well.

1 Like

#4

Any response from the mcneel team? Can Clipper be incorporated into Rhino?

3 Likes

#5

Still a bug. Apparently, in closed curves, it randomly chooses the inside.
I have ran into this in two separate projects.

0 Likes

( Charles C.) #6

Clipper shout definitly incorporated to GH and rhino…

1 Like

(Pfotiad0) #7

Read this old but good thingy (the general case is PolyCurve offset):

anoffsetalgorithm.pdf (723.4 KB)

0 Likes