I’ve spent the past few years working extensively in Alibre and recently started exploring NURBS in Rhino8. I’m developing a line of model train passenger car kits and the roof ends are giving me some frustration. I have the original drawings and photographs and with that have finished about 90% of the roof contour design. I’m struggling near the corners where a hip runs between two compound curves. I know what I want to do in Rhino but my skillset just isn’t there yet. I’d like to hire someone to help get this file over the finish line so that I can get these kits into production. If you have the skills and willingness to help with this project please contact me.
Just post a Rhino 8 file with a roof end that you currently have, and mark what you are not content with, and also mark the “non-negotiable” curves/sections, where the roof end must fit other parts of the carriage. I’m sure you get support on this forum; lots of very capable and helpful people here.
The best approach is to build an intermediate surface. It could be a regular single-span surface (or a few of them if one is not enough), a blend surface, or a blend edge.
I can take this over the finish line in Rhino 8. For the roof corners I would rebuild the hip as a clean boundary curve, then patch the transition with Network Surface or Sweep2 so both compound curves meet it tangent or curvature continuous. I would then check the result with zebra and curvature analysis so the surfaces join into a watertight solid ready for production. If useful, I can also export it as STL or STEP.
I have worked with Rhino and Grasshopper for over 15 years, building clean NURBS surfaces and preparing files for CNC, laser and 3D printing.
Could you send me the .3dm file, the original drawings and photos, the scale of the kit and how the roof will be produced? Please also tell me your deadline. I will reply with a fixed price before any work starts.
Thanks; what @Rhino_Bulgaria suggests looks promising. But before you get to that, it is necessary to “clean up” the primary curves, because if your primary curves have problems, then the primary surfaces will have problems, and then secondary curves/surfaces will also have problems. Some NURBS modelling “bare essentials” here.
This should be made into a quote, print it out on the fanciest of paper quality in existence with a real gold frame and hang it up on every office wall.
Something to get you started. Again, only you know the tolerances you need, and which curves can be simplified and by how much - but you can certainly not work with arcs ending on lines or flat surfaces and obtain G2.
I’m only now beginning to understand how much I don’t understand. I’m so far behind the eight ball that I don’t even know the terms that you’re using. Let me walk you through to where I am right now.
I’ve attached a ‘wire frame’ version of the roof end [edit; I don’t see a way to attach a file anymore]. As you can see in the original post with the blueprints from Pullman there are given radiuses at known locations. Those are the wire frames that I used to fill in the gaps. Obviously, this technique is too crude to get the results that I’m wanting as my rendering is much rougher than Lagom’s.
The models will be printed in 1:87.1 and 1:164 so the contours don’t have to be aerospace exact but close enough to a discerning modeler when comparing the print to a photograph.
I think I’m above average in parametric modeling with Alibre but I’m clearly not even crawling with Rhino yet. I have two kits almost ready to go but the roof end is hanging me up. I’m almost resigned to just hiring someone to get it completed as I don’t know how long it would take for me to get up to speed with Rhino.
Don’t worry about the terminology like g2. The Pullman engineers that designed this would also not have a clue what that means. The individual panels that are riveted together don’t even have good tangent continuity as can be seen from the photos.
To make it accurate to the original you would want the surface edges to not even touch the next panel since they overlap with some small thickness creating a small step between surfaces. .
I would approach it as Bobi suggested Roof_end.3dm (270.8 KB)