Rhino BETA Feature: Global Edge Continuity

Really nice addition.

Maybe worth the option to create a point geometry in the position of Max deviation for later consideration such adding a knot.

I would add a new knot only if raising the degree by 1-2-3 steps does not help. Knots add unwanted indentarion of the shape. In the past I used to add more knots. Now I raise the degree.

Adding a knot at the max deviation point makes no sense, the knot might have to be added completely somewhere else for the most reduction.

You’re right but not all the time you need A-class modeling.

For 3D prints,you better to be fast than smooth. I need to recostruct imported file, especcially when they come from SWks, and I’ve to make them watertight without spending days.

Inserting a knot using InsertKnot does not change the shape of the surface. (Inserting a control point using InsertControlPoint does change the shape.) After the knot is inserted control points can be moved, either directly or using a tool such as MatchSrf, to modify the shape of the surface as desired.

Inserting a knot allows for more local refinement of the shape.

In aware of this, but 99% of the time extra knots are used to add local detail, followed by control point “massaging” or matching the surface. Both operations distort the surface and lead to an unwanted indentarion where the extra knots are located. :upside_down_face: This is why I no longer do that and always try to refine a surgace by raising its degree instead.

Nobody with their mind is adding extra knots without an intention to modify the surface at the very area that was overly-crowded by knots.

RH-89124 is fixed in Rhino WIP

Will GEC in rhino 9 be scrptable?
I wish to analyse a big file by layer /or by object-
and ideally would get a log file or report- will somrthing like this be possible?

I will look into what’s possible. Note that GlobalEdgeContinuity is built on RhinoCommon. All the analysis functions that I am using are availbale, so you can analyze surfaces already with scripting if you need to.

In the latest Rhino WIP edge analysis updates live while making edits to your surfaces. This should make it much easier to tune in a surface to G1 or G2, especially on multiple edges at once. If you are using the new UVN gumball, tuning G1 on two opposite edges with a single control point becomes possible.
gec-live

One thing that I can’t understand is why the “GEC” refuses to analyze adjacent edges that are about 0,8 mm apart. I tried many different settings in the filter, but I could not find a way to activate the analysis. It happened on several pairs already.

On the other hand, the regular “Edge continuity” tool is capable of showing these distance deviations even if the gap is much greater.

it should find those if the G0 filter is set to 1.

new in today’s beta, is the ability to show max deviation of multiple edges:

gec-multi-select

Finally! Great upgrade! Thank you!

@Gijs
Will the GEC now or later in Rhino 9 also write a log File or something?
It would be extremly useful when automating checking many files and compare results!

I can’t find a setting that will let me set individual graph scale for G0, G1 and G2. For the moment I’m forced to constantly write different numbers when I switch from G0 to G1 or G2…
For example, depending on the case, for G0 I need a value in the range of 100-500, for G1 I may need 100 or 1000, and for G2 I typically need anything between 1 and 10.

Thanks @Rhino_Bulgaria logged as RH-99653 GlobalEdgeContinuity: Separate graph scale for G0, G1 and G2
and @jj1 logged as RH-99654 GlobalEdgeContinuity: Export results to a log file

Feature request: Please, allow finer values for the Evaluation settings. The G1 is restricted to just 0,001 degrees, which makes it impossible to evaluate the tangency with a greater precision of the numerical baloons across the edge pair.

The only partial solution is to increase the size of the Graph scale, but this is not a replacement for the actual numbers.

Check the following video after the 4:20 minute to see why this functionality is necessary: