Rhino 7 - Reflect

Hopefully they aren’t so heavy handed as to leave a mark…

2 Likes

As @Michael_Pryor suggested, more words are usually helpful describing your problems.
What seems obvious from one perspective may be off the radar completely from another.
In this case, I try Reflect on my computer and see that it works then have no idea what to try that would duplicate what you are doing.

Anyway, assuming that when you run the Reflect command and answer the prompts you get a symmetrical shape that’s half dark gray, but changing the light colored side doesn’t cause the dark side to change, explain exactly what edit you do to the light side and upload a file that has the symmetry set but doesn’t update.

Also, include what specific version of Rhino you’re using ie( 7.2.21041 ).

  • I am using : Version 7
    (7.2.21021.7001, 21-01-2021)
    Educational Lab License
    SN: 6-1700-0104-1-362-57225
    Windows User, KGLAKADEMI

*when I run Reflect command the 2 halves get adjusted symmetrically & one half is grayed out. but afterward when I start to edit it is not reflecting. I could even edit the gray half! which should not be possible if it was working?

  • To be very specific I can send you the file if you like. (& if I know where to send it : )

I have of course tried in other files, new file, new primitive geometries. reset Tools, restart Rhino, restart the PC. it fails always. that means it is not related to a certain file but rather to my Rhino7

Thanks for the info.

Do you mean that you make some edits that update symmetry, then as you’re editing, the updates stop working?
Or when you reopen the file updates don’t work?
Is there any event that seems related to the Reflect updates stopping?

Please do send a file. The easiest way if it’s not too big is to drag the 3dm file onto a post here.
If you don’t have an example small enough to do that, you can send it here: Rhino - Upload to Support - Put in the comment there that it’s for me (lowell@mcneel.com).
Thanks

Hi Lowell … actually I have no file cause I stopped in modelling the chair from the start once I found the symmetry is not working (the I worked in stead in Fusion 360)
But I even want to send you just an empty file with a subD cube saved in my Rhino7. Maybe you can see something wrong there
Thanks very much for care

Hello - yes, please send a simple file where Reflect as been applied and does not update.

-Pascal

Here’s the file:
Reflect_problem.3dm (197.1 KB)

There was a bug where updating stopped with History updating turned off, and did not come back, I wonder if that is what happened to this file.

-Pascal

Good. I forgot that.
@samerhanna - Please check that history update is enabled.
Right click Record History on the Rhino status bar and verify that History update is chexcked and Lock Children is not checked
Then see if Reflect works right

Okaaay ! Intersecting! so the update children should be checked !
I am sorry I get a little confused about Rhino history & SubD reflect. I thought that Subd Reflect controls that automatically, specially when I see the gray tone.
& I know that it’s not possible to work with history always on. (I teach Rhino to architects)
grateful for your support :pray:t5:
well… I catch then this opportunity to ask you some issues in SubD:

  • What is option “Snap to reflection plane ( SnapStyle=Automatic ): SnapStyle
    SnapStyle ( None Automatic Distance )” ??? I could not find it in F1 (help)

  • Why there is no toolbar button for MultiPipe that is actually a subDpipe (which is a powerful command) ?
    there is an option inside pipe (multiple) but it is another thing.
    & I know that you can create your own button by painting some pixel … but i would be nice to call it SubDPipe & give it the concession like Sweep etc.

  • Why there is not HotKey that toggle the activation of SubD selection vertex, edge, face by one click? like in T-spline (instead of filter). I know you can make your own aliases but then you have to click for the alias (maybe 2times on a letter then Enter to confirm the selection mode = 3 xclick)

  • why there is no radial symmetry ? I saw they make a polar array with history active. but this could not always be the case that you have a separate element. what if you want to apply it to a face within the shape?

Again 1000 thanks a lot for your help

2 Likes

Because of the kind of confusion you and others have had, Reflect has been separated from History. As of 7.4 I think, history settings will no longer control Reflect updates.
History Updates can be on without having History recording on though, so it’s often not a conflict
History recording has no interaction with Reflect

Snap to reflection plane is to true-up vertices that are not exactly on the reflection plane, but close so you don’t get little sliver faces with Reflect.

Toolbars haven’t caught up with the development of Multipipe

The hot-key stuff is beyond my knowledge. Try asking directly on the forum and you might get a better answer.

Hopefully Radial symmetry will come along fairly soon, but just doesn’t exist yet

1 Like

Hello- run ToolbarReset and close and restart Rhino to see the most current toolbars for the service release you are running.

-Pascal

Thanks

Yes it does ! thanks

Okay … a question in SubD:

A well known technique in modelling in SubD is to append faces to get the flow of isocurves as you want along a 2D shape. then extrude the shape in normal direction. But I am lacking a tool that makes like “Thickness in T-splines”.
Offset subD is very useful but it is not the solution for that.
Fill Hole is neither

the only way I found out is that I can apply Reflect to the half then remove the symmetry immediately. but even that gives an extra thickness & ‘unnecessary’ layer of isocurves & need some adjustment afterward to come back to the original desired thickness.
is there a better way to do it?

A post was split to a new topic: SubD offsets uneven

Hej Pascal

This is a legal closed solid without any non-manifold edges. Is it possible to remove the cap and give it any size of thickness ? I’ ve tried offset srf, Shell, Mesh offset, even quadrify it into a SubD and tried SudD thickness … non of them have worked

Regards,
snail.3dm (1.6 MB)

Udklip

The surface in the center looks to be folding a bit funnilly (screenshot with backfaces differently colored):

image

I would think that if you can get that fixed you’ll be able to use thickness better.

A post was split to a new topic: How to save an alpha channel in Rhino render window