Linetypes don't scale properly when cut

I’ve steered around most the bugs I’m encountered but this one seems to be check mate. The lines shown are supposed to be the same scale. But they aren’t.

And there’s no way around it (that I know of). For a second I thought why don’t I just override the linetype in detail view and make different line types for each scale… but you can’t do that unfortunately (feature request: Linetype overrides in details?)

Linetype Scaling Section Test.3dm (68.7 KB)
#-kCs-TEST.ini (14.1 KB)

To be honest I think I need the tracking list for everything wrong with layouts/printing. I was going to post about the line thickness issues because I finally figured it out… well probably part of it. Bug testing is kind of line an onion it’s just one layer after another after another. There’s just too much going on all at once.

The thing is that I need to know what’s on deck to be fixed because it’s both going to affect how I set up this template and also dictate what’s worth investing time into and what isn’t.

The lines are just curves. They are scaling properly. It’s the 3D geometry that isn’t (cut or not cut):

These are just the same objects in two different detail views.

I’ve also spent a very generous amount of time digging through YouTrack to see what’s going on with this and it’s not clear whether it’s being dealt with or not.

The reason I’ve been posting about this so much is because I’m setting up my template. It’s A LOT of work. If you’re just leaving things as is I can work around it. If I get a service update then I have to spend hours removing all my work-around from the template (or worse yet have other’s doing that same) that would kind of suck.

Hi Keith -
I’ve put these on the list:

  • RH-86187 Display: Section Linetype Should Follow Model Space Scale
  • RH-86196 Print: Edge Linetype Should Follow Model Space Scale
  • RH-86197 Display (and Print): Linetype Segment Lengths

Thanks,
-wim

1 Like

Wim: Thank-you so much.

It’s a tricky issue to demonstrate because a lot depends on the display mode (among other things).

Linetype Scaling Section Test.3dm (68.7 KB)

The line thickness issue is very similar but not explicitly mentioned in those issues

This is what you say about line thickness in this thread:

I’m afraid that doesn’t give me much.
There are 74 unresolved tickets that include “line” and “thickness”: https://mcneel.myjetbrains.com/youtrack/issues?q=State:%20Unresolved%20line%20thickness
(you will be seeing a few less as not all of them are public)
If you want me to file a different issue, I’ll need more information.
-wim

This is the file I should have attached. It looks like I accidentally just attached that same file from (way) above twice - I’ll double-check this one after posting. Apologies for the confusion!! But keep in mind I’ve been digging hard at this and probably burnt out pretty bad.

I think the issues are being tracked correctly because once they’re broken down to the basic issue (it’s not so easy now that there are so many settings) the problem is pretty clear. It definitely would have helped me having this sooner just so I knew why my lines weren’t looking right.

Once everything’s sorted the drawings are going to look pretty awesome. Even if half the stuff gets fixed I could probably work around the other half. I appreciate your guys’ hard work and I can see the level of difficulty given there are so many new settings, one affecting another.

Line Scaling Demo.3dm (250.3 KB)