Engineers, will this sliding block work?

I am art trained, so I’m lacking engineering knowledge and approach mechanical things with common sense. However, contrary to what many believe, I do understand that common sense is not necessarily right when applied to engineering and mechanics.

So, here is a section of a model I’m working on to 3D print. The little shaft is a spring pin, and it’s in a carriage that I intend to adjust with the bolt. I feel 10mm of travel should be enough for my purpose. Can any of the engineering types here see any glaring errors as to why this will not work? I wonder about it wanting to twist and jam running on just 1 bolt. But it is pretty small? This is bolted to a smooth substrate so the carriage and nut will be captured.

Sliding block Test.3dm (11.3 MB)

Any suggestions on the finish of the mating pieces? Should I fillet corners inside and out? Thoughts, suggestions? This test piece is about a 6 hour print, and I’d like to catch any obvious errors before printing.

I’m not a mechanical engineer, but have lots of experience designing and manufacturing — mostly 3D printing — such contraptions for personal projects.

It would make the most sense to print the “female” part like this.

I’d get rid of all the small fillets, since they generally don’t print well, especially if they are overhangs, and replace them with 45° chamfers (>= 0.5mm). The latter print cleanly without supports and break the edges as gracefully as fillets.

Your mechanism seems okay, though there currently are no tolerances between the mating parts.
Generally, tolerances from 0.15 to 0.3mm are adequate for FDM printing. The screw hole also needs at least a 0.15mm tolerance and should be a teardrop shape (instead of a circle) depending on the print orientation. Circular holes generally don’t print well unless they are printed lying in the XY-plane of the print bed.

Use a regular nut, glue it in place (if necessary), and grease it well.
Overall a better hardware choice would be a trapezoidal thread spindle with a copper nut, instead of a screw and bolt, which are really meant for fastening.

PLA would probably work better than PETG for this?

For the parts to glide well you’d also have to sand all relevant contact surfaces to get rid of the layer lines.

If you don’t want to do that simply make the mating surfaces from a different material.
You could for instance make inlays from thin PTFE sheets that slide along each other with very low friction, but the rest would be 3D-printed.

If you want the screw to act as an axle, it should probably also go through the front of the larger part. This could potentially make the linear movement more stable and prevent the small carriage from moving laterally.

Some of this is going to depend on how this thing is going to be used. Is it constantly/frequently being moved back and forth, or is it simply an occasional adjustment? Also, how to approach it will also depend on the tools you have at hand and your skills with them. I’ve spent my life doing various sorts of fab (model/prototype maker) and have tons of tools, so I’m maybe making some assumptions that don’t work for you.

As far as I can see, your sliding method isn’t really going to work well, because the bolt is not captured in the base block. So unscrewing it for example will likely just unscrew the bolt and not move the sliding block. What you want is a fully captured screw. IMO, the easiest way to do this with off-the-shelf hardware is to get a longer fully-threaded bolt and have it go all the way trhough the base block, and on the other side use an elastic stop nut (locknut) with which you can adjust how much play is left. Your sliding block will then be fully guided and held in place by the screw.

The principle of the captured nut inside the slot in the slider looks OK, but you need a small amount of clearance which you haven’t modeled in. In principle you should not need to glue anything. You also need some clearance between the sides of the slider and the slot in the base block.

As far as 3D printed holes go, I have a tendency to model them slightly undersize with a decent inner wall thickness, and then drill them out to the correct size (but I have a full set of mm drills in 0.1mm increments on hand). PLA, ABS and the like drill very nicely. Holes in the horizontal direction of the printer are always problematic, and sometimes difficult to avoid. You can teardrop shape them as mentioned above, but if you need a full round hole, you can just let them fill with support and drill them out later. Another tactic is to turn the holes into slots which are then filled in with a second 3D printed piece glued or screwed into place to create the hole.

In addition to Helvetosaur’s suggestion for capturing the bolt with an elastic nut I would suggest that unless it is truly a once-or-twice set and forget adjustment that you put flat washers under the bolt head and elastic nut as a wear surface to protect the plastic base block. Especially if there is any sort of respectable load on the slider while adjusting.

Thanks for the responses and good info. I should have included an image of the whole contraption with some additional info. I was rushing to post late last night.

I only print in PETG as everything I make needs more durability and outdoor capability than I’ve gotten with PLA. ABS is out, as I print in my living space, and real ventilation is not possible.

In my rush to post, I did not create the tolerance gaps for movement. I usually give 1.25mm. But bigger may be necessary with this in some areas.

This is a thought and ties in with,

I did not think of that. However, there is supposed to be spring tension on it, but the springs are on a diagonal most of the time. I’m not sure how that might affect the slide?

I can’t see me having to move it often after it’s set. The weight of the tool might change depending on disk type.

I have to say I’ve been hugely impressed with the results from my new (last year) printer. It is unbelievable when compared to the contraption I had before. The horizontal holes it prints using tree supports have so far been good enough for my work.

Sounds like a good idea. Does creating the inner wall thickness affect all the other walls, or can you increase wall thickness at specific locations? If so, would that be a slicer feature?

I have not tried this for a hole. Nice.

I did not post the whole project, as I usually test print portions of the model, to be sure holes, hinges, etc., work before I embark on a full print. i.e., the piece in OP.

I am really pressed for space and make most things to fold or disassemble. The piece I posted is part of this 4-1/2" angle grinder jig I’m hoping to 3D print. I made a simple grinder clamp/hinge/base, and used it already to do some repeated threaded rod cuts. Since it worked well, I decided to try adding some more bits like the springs and alignment bar. It will disassemble for closet storage. Here’s a pic of the whole thing as I intend it. I used an available Bosch grinder model in this, but the clamp part fits my cheap Harbor Freight Bauer grinder. The clamp and alignment arm will be model specific, and the arm should probably be made from metal, but I’ll most likely make one from plastic to test and as a template.

What are you cutting with that? If it’s steel (you mentioned threaded rod), assuming that’s an abrasive cutoff wheel, if that’s a plastic 3D printed base, it’s gonna get melted pretty fast… And make sure your clamping system is sturdy.

These types of projects are fun to plan and build, but as a working tool they are (IMO) of limited functionality. But of course I’m horribly spoiled having had access to excellent shops all my working life, and even now in retirement I still have a great space and more tools than any one person should have… :winking_face_with_tongue:

Metal profile cutting saws can be relatively cheap these days, and my preference is for a “cold” saw - not fond of abrasive cutoffs. But they’re heavy and take up a lot of space, and a good one will still set you back like $500.

Bearing in mind that you can’t cut beyond the disc washers, you seem to have designed in a lot of unnecessary clearance. To minimise flexing and vibration I’d suggest you sacrifice some of this and attach the mount to the grinder closer to the disk, and also reduce the height of the mount as much as possible.

And as @Helvetosaur says, the angle grinder is going to be blasting the mount with shards of hot metal. I’d add a metal (or sacrificial wood) shield.

Have fun and stay safe.
Jeremy

It is to cut bolts, rods, and maybe 1" flat bars. And No. The base is not plastic; it is wood covered with melamine. Nor is the V guide (not shown), which is aluminium angle. As I said, the throwaway version worked very well, and this should continue to be fine for my small projects.

I worked in design and construction most of my life and always had full wood and metal shops (MIG, TIG, etc.) to use, plus my garage setup when I had a house. That is in the past. I now live in a small city apartment, and conserving space and weight is paramount. Cost is second, and this little tool may eventually cost $40 in hardware. Though I’ve always had exceptional professional tools, I don’t need professional quality anymore. Also, these little projects are fun and keep me using Rhino.

I love where I live, except for my loss of work space. I can’t restore motorcycles without space, so I’ve switched to bicycles, which I can do inside my place. And all my small projects that require power tools and make a mess, I can sometimes do them outside. But storage will always be a factor. You can’t imagine how removing the jig from the flat base simplifies storage.

The actual Bauer grinder sits further in the clamp, as opposed to the Bosch in the model. As I mentioned, the original simple version worked for my purposes. So I figured I’d try to add the two features that would have been good to have on that project, a spring return and a lock-off for a fixed angle. Locking it off made it easy to grind the ends of the threaded rod so nuts went on easily. The parts I haven’t tried/made are the new alignment arm and springs/adjusters.

Thanks, everyone, for the info/help.