Bug, Move Face needs error check + message

Rhino
#1

Check file, try subselect top and move up with gumball.
Rhino needs to recognize situations that doesn’t work with move face AND report messups like this.

image
image780×661 66.9 KB

When exploded and points turned on it looks like this:

image
image867×693 84.2 KB

Why are the extra isoparm moved to 0? Is the calculations happening in a local 0,0,0 that is forgotten to be xformed back to world???

As you can see here, if I make multiple and do it to them all, then all of these share the same location for this messed up isocurve:

image
image1540×779 167 KB

Move top face messes up.3dm (75.5 KB)

#2

I posted this with an almost identical example awhile back…

1 Like
#3

I believe it is https://mcneel.myjetbrains.com/youtrack/issue/RH-27554

#4

6 years, two versions and nothing done… :face_with_raised_eyebrow:

#5

Maybe it’s a self fulfilling prophecy… If nobody uses it, it is no need to fix it, and if you don’t fix it nobody will use it… :smiley:

I really hope facemanipulation can get some real love in V8.
Both the distoriting tool that we have now, and a new one where the surrounding surfaces are kept intact and just extended when needed. (Like spaceclaim does) I often need to rotate a face a bit, but that just messes everything up in Rhino.

image
image1087×385 79.7 KB

Of course sometimes the current behaviour is needed as the face being moved IS the master shape, so both tools needs to work side by side.

#6

This isn’t the only thing in Rhino that falls into that category!

Since it’s clearly a bug (at least from the user’s point of view) why not fix it in V7?

#7

Yeah…

Absolutely!

Philip

#8

Yeah, please squash the bug in b6 too, but I don’t expect new feaures like content aware face manipulation to make it into v7.