Analysis Tools' Switch – unequal behaviour

Hi,

I noticed that switching off the global edge continuity dialogue with the new switch at the upper right side of the window also collapses it. This is a useful UI thing imo. However, other analysis tools like curvature graph, zebra etc, do not do this.

Is there a reason for the different behaviour of the switch across tools?

Thanks

yes, GlobalEdgeContinuity is a dialog, not a panel, so it can’t be docked and therefore takes more place in the UI. Therefore collapsing it when not in use.

I could change GEC to a panel, but that would mean I need to revise the UI a bit. I find it currently too wide for conveniently fitting it into a panel compared to other analysis tools.

I don’t know if panels can collapsed this way, but even if there was, I don’t think this is a good idea, since these analysis panels can be docked with other panels.

Hi Gijs, if you remember, some time ago in another topic I proposed to add a 2nd switch to collapse the GEC window when the tool is in active use. That would make it much more usable for those of us who are more interested to see the visual feedback directly on the 3d model rather than the numbers in the vertical list.

Is it possible to implement that 2nd switch before the release of Rhino 9?

Could panels (when in the floating state) be collapsible using the switch? When docked, the swich could be disabled. It’s a neat and tidy way of decluttering the working area on the fly.

This would be handy – also for floating panels. I’m constantly shifting panels out of the way to see the model, especially when multiple are in use.

I think the best way forward would be to:

  1. Convert GEC to a panel
    RH-97727 GEC: convert to panel
  2. Add a collapse function to floating panels
    RH-97728 Allow floating containers to collapse

Sounds good. Thanks

maybe like this, avoiding another button:

That could work. For something visible to the user, could a ‘minimize’ button be added next to the close x to the upper corner (like on other windows) ?

Instead of minimizing to the bottom, it collapses (like the current GEC dialogue)

yes, another button is possible, but I’d like to avoid it, since it takes valuable space.

For collapsing we normally use this sign > rather than -

It’s quite small

It’s quite small and would be consistent with other windows

Cool

I’m first going to try this with single clicking on tab. After doing some testing, this seems to work very well. It gives a nice hit area. Once implemented, I’ll send you a build to try it out.

Is there any chance to add an up or down arrow (^ that changes to v, and vice versa) indicating the current state of the window, as well as the area to be clicked?

well, if I add that, then I can just as well make it a button, and I don’t really have a good place to put it. Let’s first try it without and see how that feels. I think the collapsed panel height is enough visual indication that it is collapsed.

RH-97728 is fixed in Rhino BETA